More on the chat

Arya dequardo at waisman.wisc.edu
Fri Mar 5 04:36:08 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 92155

 "Geoff Bannister" <gbannister10 at a...> wrote:
>
> Having skimmed through some of the chat session (I shall be setling 
> down in bed for a good read before bye-byes later on)I was led to 
> wonder what sort of selection process was applied to the 16000 
> questions which JKR says were submitted because some of them were 
> totally useless in terms of finding things out about Harry. For 
> example....
> Anyone else share my irritation at this sort of bandwidth wasting?

--------
Hello!!! You could have asked as many questions as you liked just like I did!!  
She was not JUST chatting with kids.  There was a post (# 91994 by 
Entropymail) that gave everyone one of us the link to where we could submit 
all the questions we could dream up starting at 7pm CST.  I don't know about 
you but I sure as hell spent a good two hours thinking up questions that were 
unique, had a chance at being chosen and might help give us clues.  I 
probably submitted over 50 questions under more than one name (in case 
they only let one question per name--which was NOT the case--grrr!)  
Anywho....I got one question in and asked (Is Harry related to GG?) sure I got 
a non-commital answer but as is the case with JKR, that tells us something in 
that it's not a 'No' and for whatever reason, she wants that left unanswered 
for now.  So....don't complain about the questions when you could have done 
just as much as I did to try to saturate the question pool with good non-
moronic (did you know they ride brooms backwards?) questions!!  

Arya (Who's been smiling all day since she saw a question got through!)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive