[HPforGrownups] Snape NOT a Vampire (Was The Marauders are all Gryff...

[CareALotsClouds at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 92202

In a message dated 05/03/04 15:33:30 GMT Standard Time, 
siriuslove71 at yahoo.com writes:


> This is not a hot topic for me as I could care less if Snape was a 
> Vampire or not.  But...if JK did answer the question in any of the 
> above mentioned ways some would automatically come to the conclusion 
> that there is a connection.  JK could have said, "no, there is not a 
> connection" and the subject would have been dropped.  She did not.  
> She left it open to discussion, which I think is brilliant on her 
> part. Diana 
> 

I think JK is very awkward when questions are asked by her fans that are, in 
her mind, have something to do with the plot and the question has some truth 
in it.  So she does answer them awkwardly, not wanting to answer so she answers 
in the way of 'Wait and see'.  I think you are right in saying that if she 
says this then she knows that we are going to know there is something up.  But 
then again, with this Vampire question she said 'No'.  I think she knows it is 
discussed so much that she didnt want to spoil to many theories.  Fact of the 
matter is she said 'No'.  She may of said 'erm' to throw us of but she said 
'No' and I dont think she would lie to her fans.  But like Diana says she has 
left it open for very hopeful !vampireSnape fans, it does sound like a 'No' 
though

Personally I always thought the theory was a bit silly, but thats just IMHO.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]