Snape NOT a Vampire (Was The Marauders are all Gryff...

[Diana_Sirius_fan]

No: HPFGUIDX 92208

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, CareALotsClouds at a... wrote:
> I think JK is very awkward when questions are asked by her fans 
that are, in 
> her mind, have something to do with the plot and the question has 
some truth 
> in it.  So she does answer them awkwardly, not wanting to answer so 
she answers 
> in the way of 'Wait and see'.  I think you are right in saying that 
if she 
> says this then she knows that we are going to know there is 
something up.  But 
> then again, with this Vampire question she said 'No'.  I think she 
knows it is 
> discussed so much that she didnt want to spoil to many theories.  
Fact of the 
> matter is she said 'No'.  She may of said 'erm' to throw us of but 
she said 
> 'No' and I dont think she would lie to her fans.  But like Diana 
says she has 
> left it open for very hopeful !vampireSnape fans, it does sound 
like a 'No' 
> though
> 
> Personally I always thought the theory was a bit silly, but thats 
just IMHO.
> 
Actually she did not say "Erm, No". The 'fact of the matter' is that 
she said "Erm, I don't think so" which is very different from no.  
Diana