Imperio'd Member of the Order (WAS: Snape's position)

[suehpfan]

No: HPFGUIDX 92572

snip
>  I'm still sure  ESE!Lupin is the spy but much more obviously, it 
> could be Snape.  We never did find out what happened to that 
> missing invisibility cloak. Did Podmore have it when he was 
> arrested or did it fall into Voldemort's hands?
> 
>  If so, then there might have been an invisible Death Eater in the 
> room when Sirius died. And of course it wouldn't be the first time 
> that Snape used an invisibility cloak to sneak up on Harry.
> 
> 
> Pippin

Oh Pippin, bless you!  Another bad boy Snape post.  I was beginning 
to feel like the lone Snape doubter. I don't buy the ESE!Lupin theory 
(too much of a bleeding heart, I'm afrad) but there has to be 
something more to what is going on with Snape.  He should be dead.  
since he's not dead "poor Snape, always looking out for Harry" 
doesn't fly with me. If he was unable to stop the events at the MoM 
from happening or warn Harry that it was coming what use is he to the 
Order anyway?  What is he actually doing when everyone else is trying 
to stop LV from getting the "weapon"?

Where *is* Snape when all of these things happen to Harry?  The only 
thing we know for sure is that he isn't there (or at least, we can't 
see him) we only have Snape's word for his where abouts at the time 
of the MoM at least.  I think it is just as likely that lovely Bella 
did send the curse that killed Sirius, but the image of Snape in an 
invisibility cloak, zapping him through the vail is appealing.  

As I said in an earlier post however, having Sirius alive and access 
to Kreacher as a spy in the Order's headquarters might be a good 
thing for Voldy and his crew. With Sirius dead, will creature still 
be around?  I'm with the head on the wall group here.  Not much use 
to Malfoy that way.

Sue