Imperio'd Member of the Order (WAS: Snape's position)

[sedyn2000]

No: HPFGUIDX 92601

Pippin wrote:
> snip
> >  I'm still sure  ESE!Lupin is the spy but much more obviously, it 
> > could be Snape.  We never did find out what happened to that 
> > missing invisibility cloak. Did Podmore have it when he was 
> > arrested or did it fall into Voldemort's hands?
> > 
> > If so, then there might have been an invisible Death Eater in the 
> > room when Sirius died. And of course it wouldn't be the first time 
> > that Snape used an invisibility cloak to sneak up on Harry.

Sue wrote:
> Where *is* Snape when all of these things happen to Harry?  The only 
> thing we know for sure is that he isn't there (or at least, we can't 
> see him) we only have Snape's word for his where abouts at the time 
> of the MoM at least.  I think it is just as likely that lovely Bella 
> did send the curse that killed Sirius, but the image of Snape in an 
> invisibility cloak, zapping him through the vail is appealing.  

But there are two members of the Order who can see through 
invisibility cloaks: Dumbledore and Moody. I can't remember where 
Moody was of that time but Dumbledore was in the room and I don't 
think Snape would risk zapping Sirius right in front of Dumbledore 
even if he was distracted.

~Sedyn