Does LV know it was Snape who sent the Order to the MoM? (Was: Snape the Coward?
cubfanbudwoman
susiequsie23 at sbcglobal.net
Fri Mar 12 12:29:57 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 92804
Carol wrote:
> <snip> Dumbledore wasn't at Hogwarts and couldn't have known that
> Harry was heading for the MoM unless someone told him, and who else
> could it be besides Snape? <snip>
Max responded:
> > Kreacher.
Carol again:
> But my point is that LV and Malfoy *knew* that DD was not at
> Hogwarts and therefore could not have known about Harry going to
> the MoM if Snape hadn't contacted either him or the Order or both.
> There was no one else at Hogwarts who could have done it.
<snip>
> Can you think of a lie that could excuse him or
> someone else he could blame without betraying the Order?
<snip>
> Sorry. I don't follow. How would the Order have known that Harry
> was missing (and heading for the MoM) if Snape hadn't told them?
Susan:
Ummmm. I thought I addressed this in post #92652. In that, I
talked about a couple of lies which I believe could have worked.
Here:
>>>A couple of possibilities for alternative scenarios I can think of
are:
1) Is it not possible (though not very exciting, I'll grant), that
Harry could have left a note w/ someone? Maybe another DA member,
with instructions to owl it to an Order member [Dung, Moody,
Kingsley, Tonks]?
2) Is it not also possible, given how owls can find *anyone*, that
Harry could have run up to the owlery himself before leaving and sent
an owl to DD? [We have canon for this possibility. Remember Harry
sending owls to Sirius when Sirius was on the run?]
Those aren't very exciting possibilities, but they are at least other
possibilities than that Snape contacted DD to tell him about Harry's
rushing off to the MoM.<<<
Again, we know they're not true, but would Voldy know? Voldy knows
that Potter has allies, even if he doesn't know about The Order
itself [and I suspect that he does]. Passing along one of these
tales [#2 seems more likely, to me] could get Snape off the hook,
could it not?
Siriusly Snapey Susan
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive