Petunia had no choice
tipgardner
tipgardner at netscape.net
Thu Mar 18 02:36:12 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 93292
udder_pen_dragon wrote:
> Del :said
> Moreover, the fact that DD didn't seem to worry about baby Harry
> being in danger while out there on the doorstep all night, makes me
> think that the charm had *already* been sealed, *before* Petunia had
> any say in the decision.
That doesn't necessarily follow. For one thing DD's voice says that
she has agreed to the pact in OotP, doesn't it? Also, once Voldie had
fallen that did not appear to be a threat and certainly no DEs would
know where HP's muggle relatives lived yet.
udder_pen_dragon:
> I believe that Petunia was aware of her sister's situation in
advance and she knew what would be happening in the event of James and
Lilly's death and Harry living.
Sirius would have taken in Harry had he not been implicated in Harry's
parents' murders, not Petunia.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive