Petunia had no choice

Serena Moonsilver serenamoonsilver at yahoo.com
Thu Mar 18 12:58:32 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 93322


> udder_pen_dragon:
> > I believe that Petunia was aware of her sister's situation in
> advance and she knew what would be happening in the event of James 
and
> Lilly's death and Harry living.
> 
and tipgardner wrote:
> Sirius would have taken in Harry had he not been implicated in 
Harry's
> parents' murders, not Petunia.

Actually, at the time those events took place, Sirius had not 
confronted Peter yet so there was no reason that he couldn't have 
taken Harry with him other than Dumbledore had ordered Hagrid to 
bring him to Privet Drive.   So, at least at that point it had 
already been decided (by Dumbledore) that Harry would have to live 
with his relatives...


Serena





More information about the HPforGrownups archive