How did Moaning Myrtle Make the Water Splash?
Doriane
delwynmarch at yahoo.com
Fri Mar 19 09:35:21 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 93382
> > (Bobby's comment)
> > Here is another trivial problem I don't understand: In COS,
> > Moaning Myrtle made a splash in her restroom when HRH were
> > there - but how did she move the water?
(snip)
> > (Kimberly's comments)
> > Very good question, one that I myself have questioned. My
> > initial thought is that perhaps she is a Poltergeist like Peeves
> > and can indeed manipulate matter for lack of a better phrase.
> > We also have the comment from Hermione that Myrtle likes to
> > throw tantrums and flood the bathroom. (CoS, US ed. pg.
> > 133). If she can't manipulate matter, how could she possible
> > cause the bathroom to flood ?
Del :
We know she's immune to matter being thrown at her, at least,
because she gets completely upset when Ron says that throwing a book
at her can't hurt her (you know, the whole "Let's play at throwing
things at Myrtle : 10 points if you get it through her stomach" or
something like that - I don't have my books, sorry).
Of course, that doesn't mean she can't *manipulate* matter. But
since other ghosts can't, she'd have to be a special ghost. That
could be : maybe being killed by a Basilisk turns you into a
specific kind of ghost ?
And in the list of "How can Myrtle...", here's my favourite : how
can Myrtle be dragged all the way to the lake when someone flushes
her toilet ? The first time I read it, I found it a) yucky, b)
hilarious, and c) impossible ("But... She's a ghost !")
Del
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive