[HPforGrownups] How did Moaning Myrtle Make the Water Splash?
Kimberly
ekrbdg at msn.com
Fri Mar 19 02:45:06 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 93371
(Bobby's comment)
Here is another trivial problem I don't understand: In COS, Moaning
Myrtle made a splash in her restroom when HRH were there - but how
did she move the water? I mean the ghosts at Hogwarts can walk
through the walls and floors and cannot move anything. When Nearly
Headless Nick needed to make a commotion to help Harry, he had to
get Peeves the Poltergeist to push over a cabinet - Nick couldn't
move anything. Also in the Deathday party, the ghosts couldn't even
smell or taste the food when they passed through the tables, let
alone move them.
So how Moaning Myrtle, a ghost, make the water move? (Or for that
matter, how does she remain cozy in her favorite U-bend in the
pipes? Shouldn't she just pass through the sides of the pipe when
she wasn't looking, as it were?)
(Kimberly's comments)
Very good question, one that I myself have questioned. My initial thought is that perhaps she is a Poltergeist like Peeves and can indeed manipulate matter for lack of a better phrase. We also have the comment from Hermione that Myrtle likes to throw tantrums and flood the bathroom. (CoS, US ed. pg. 133). If she can't manipulate matter, how could she possible cause the bathroom to flood ?
Anyone have any thoughts on this ?
Kimberly
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive