Learning Apparition (was: Shortest..summer)
dorapye
helenhorsley at hotmail.com
Sun Mar 21 20:41:18 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 93582
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "meriaugust" <meriaugust at y...>
wrote:
>
> You can't get your aparition liscence until you are 17, but I
would
> assume that most wizard kids practice before hand so they can pass
> the test as soon as they come of age, like the twins did. (Sort of
> like how us American Muggles can't get drivers liscences until we
> are 16 and a half, or our learners permits til we are 16, but we
> still start practicing.) So maybe DD could give Harry a little
> apparition ed?
dorapye:
Ah, but in the UK, you can't actually *get* your 'Provisional
Driving Licence' in order to learn to drive until your 17th
birthday...can't help thinking that JKR would be more likely to
apply UK RW rules to her WW than, well, elsewhere rules...
However, had a thought about DD teaching Harry and Co to Apparate a
bit sooner than legally allowed and it occurred to me that during
the whole DoM battle, all the kids were most probably breaking the
Restriction of Underage Magic law, as they were outside Hogwarts.
(Have I got that right?)
At the end of OotP we see no repercussions for this law-breaking,
which presumably mean that, with Fudge forced into an embarrassing
retraction of his previous assertion about Lord Thingy, DD managed
to negotiate the dropping of any charges against his students.
Is it possible that with Fudge's admission to the WW the LV is
indeed back, DD has also managed to negotiate a slackening of the
RoUM law for Harry, since it is clear that his life is in constant
threat from LV now? A kind of no-questions-asked and no-sanctions-
applied situation should Harry use magic outside of Hogwarts, during
that summer..?
This could then signal a general loosening of the Ministry laws with
regards to Harry in particular, but perhaps also other Hogwarts
students, as DD prepares him for battle. If this is the case, I'm
sure, as many people have suggested, that Apparition laws would be
amongst thtose that DD, and the Ministry, would choose to ignore,
for Harry's sake.
Whadya think?
dorapye, going back to lurking for now
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive