"You heard James?" (Was: Harry bezoared)

[vmonte]

No: HPFGUIDX 93827

Lynette wrote:
Then I think of Lupin's remark in PoA. He said "you heard James?"
(paraphrasing) to Harry during the patronus lesson.  Why?  He didn't
question Harry's hearing Lily's scream. Does he know something about
James yet to be told?

Carol wrote:
I think this remark is one of our first clues that Lupin was a good
friend of James's, a fact he's been concealing from Harry and now has
to partially admit. 

vmonte responds:
Everyone knows that Lupin was friends with James -- why would he hide 
that from Harry?  I think Lynette made a good observation. Lupin's 
remark sounds more like he was surprised that Harry heard James 
voice?! (Maybe it wasn't James's voice after all?) I think we will 
find out something curious about that night.

vmonte