Lets ask the kids (was getting anything right)

[cubfanbudwoman]

No: HPFGUIDX 94044

 Carolyn:
> Ok, as we have to admit that 11000+ adults havn't quite figured it 
> out yet, lets take a new and cunning route! Calling all you 
> parents, teachers, aunties, uncles, whatever, out there: let's hear 
> the best of the kids' take on the series/plot, and see if they have 
> spotted something that we haven't.


Susan [chortling, because many of you know how I feel about Snape, 
especially Rickman!Snape]:

The first thing which came to my mind was my 7-year-old daughter's 
comment last night.  We were watching the new PoA trailer and I 
(having watched it a mere 30 or so times before this) was 
saying "Turn to page 394" along w/ Rickman!Snape.  I laughed and 
said, "Isn't that great?"  Kristen looked at me like I was nuts and 
said, "Snape's MEAN."

Siriusly Snapey Susan...who knows on one level her daughter is 
correct but who hopes on the level that *matters* that her daughter 
is wrong.