Ollivanders' origin
severelysigune
severelysigune at yahoo.co.uk
Wed Mar 31 11:49:16 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 94648
David wrote:
<<I believe that, in Greek, the ending -ander means 'man', thus
Alexander, Menander, Anaximander. Because of this, and their great
antiquity, I had surmised that the Ollivander family came from that
part of the world. That strikes me as more plausible than a 'van
der' component from Dutch, which would require a name to follow (as
in, say, van der Waals); also I'm guessing that Dutch has changed a
lot from its ancestral language since 382 BC and that the 'van der'
form is relatively recent.
I don't know what the Alex- refers to, or if Greek was the language
of ancient Macedonia, though Alexander certainly ended up spreading
Greek language and culture through a huge area.
Anyone whose Greek is better than mine able to hazard a guess at the
Olliv- part?>>
Sigune:
Well, my Greek isn't very good, but when it comes to Dutch I can be
of some help.
First things first: the Dutch language very simply did not exist in
382 BC. The first snatch of written 'Dutch' dates back to the
eleventh century ("hebban olla vogala nestas hagunnan hinase hic enda
tu wat unbidan wi nu"); that is the point at which the language is
acknowledged as different from German. So, no, the "vander" cannot
possibly be "van der" as in some Dutch/Flemish family names.
I like your analysis of "ander" as the Greek for man, which is
undoubtedly right; but frankly "Olliv-" does not sound Greek to me at
all. Olives do, though :). Maybe it's another JKR joke. Or we are
heading in the wrong direction.
Yours severely,
Sigune
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive