Will Harry lose his powers? (Was:Book 7 predictions)
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Tue May 11 02:22:34 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 98028
> Carol adds:
> Except that his flying ability and its offshoot, his Quidditch
skills, seems to be inherited directly from James. We've yet to
see Voldemort on a broom, and there's no indication, IIRC, that
Tom Riddle ever played Quidditch. So I don't think Harry would
have been a Squib, though I agree that he would have been
much less powerful--an ordinary wizard kid like Ron--if he hadn't
acquired most of Voldemort's powers at Godric's Hollow.<
I think that's too easy. This is supposed to be a sacrifice; Harry's
got to give up something he really wants. Like Quidditch. We do
have canon for Voldemort's flying abilities, I'm afraid --
Quirrellmort not only caught the flying key in Book One, he did it
without extra help. Harry needed Ron and Hermione. Harry
certainly has his father's athletic talent, but is that magic?
>From what I've read of JKR's interviews, she doesn't like the sort
of series where the hero is the ageless, changeless protagonist
of endless sequels--I don't think she'd leave Harry to such a fate.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive