Who knows ? (But its fun to predict....) End of Book 7

[arrowsmithbt]

No: HPFGUIDX 98482

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "samnanya" <yswahl at s...> wrote:
> and so it just might come to this .........
> 
> Neville's wizarding skills continue to develop...
> Harry finally confronts Voldemort in book 7 and Voldemort 
> loses his own body (he never learns, does he?) and occupies 
> Harry's body so that Harry is now Harry!mort. Harry!mort 
> is in conflict as neither can  live while the other survives...
> But there is a resolution! Only Neville can "stand up to his
> friend" and fight him, just like he tried to do in Book 1, 
> and thus "defeat Harry!mort" to fulfill the prophecy in
> killing Voldemort's spirit just as Harry had fulfilled the
> prophecy in killing Voldemort's body. As to  which of Harry 
> and Neville survive, I can only guess, but as Neville 
> ultimately failed in book 1, i assume that he does not 
> survive, and Harry is restored. Neville's courage  is 
> recognized posthumously, as a bittersweet ending to
> the series.
> I have reasons to strongly support this scenario which I 
> will gladly explain if anyone is curious enough to try to
> demonstrate by canon as opposed to "You're an idiot for 
> thinking that!" why the above scenario will not happen  
> (especially Kneasy...) 
> 

Hey! Steady on! When have I  ever called anyone an idiot?
(Don't  claim never to  have thought it, mind.)

Supposition based on canon is always welcome on my screen,
whether I agree with it or not - 'cos when someone quotes
canon finding more canon (either supporting or refuting)
is much easier than countering a fog of wishful thinking
masquerading as analysis.

I've never paid much attention to Neville;  maybe I should.
But the theory you propose seems to back my ideas on 
possession, so it'll be of interest no matter if I agree with 
your conclusions or not. And the extract that you quote
as your post header is no more than a throw-away line,
not theory, supposition, conclusion or analysis. I can see 
that I'll have to start adding flags to my posts - *Warning-
joke coming.*

So... let's see your canon.

Kneasy