Who knows ? (But its fun to predict....) End of Book 7

[samnanya]

No: HPFGUIDX 98499

Kneasy
Hey! Steady on! When have I  ever called anyone an idiot?
(Don't  claim never to  have thought it, mind.)

Samnanya
Damn.... I have to be REALLY careful on what I say and
how I say it.  What I MEANT to say was that I respect 
your opinion, because whether I agree with it or not,
you always express yourself well and logically. I did
not mean to even remotely imply that you are an idiot.
I really WANT to hear your response because you provide
arguments for your point of view and not just dismiss 
or ignore what i or anyone else says because you dont
agree with it.

However, there are those who respond to a post here 
by not using logic, let alone canon, saying that a
theory or ship is wrong or cant happen merely because
it just CANT be right, while ignoring all the points
in its favor, and worse yet, not providing a counter
argument.

Example - Yeah I know many HP fans feel that Lupin is a good
guy, but that doesnt mean that someone can't present an
interesting argument or four supported by canon as to how 
he can indeed be evil. The theory is not IMPOSSIBLE, just
not popular, and i would LOVE for someone to tear it apart
because i cant read right, or whatever, because I really do
like Lupin, just dont necessarily trust his motives. But
for this post that is not what i am addressing. 

Canon for the Heroic!Neville, Duality!Prophecy scenarios
will follow in next post . 
Once again, sorry for the misunderstanding.
Samnanya