[HPforGrownups] Not so ESE:Lupin

[animal lover]

No: HPFGUIDX 98554


Samnanya

Example - Yeah I know many HP fans feel that Lupin is a good
guy, but that doesnt mean that someone can't present an
interesting argument or four supported by canon as to how 
he can indeed be evil. The theory is not IMPOSSIBLE, just
not popular, and i would LOVE for someone to tear it apart
because i cant read right, or whatever, because I really do
like Lupin, just dont necessarily trust his motives.

Samnanya

animallover_11:

I have been putting alot of thought into the whole ESE:Lupin and I just can't buy into that. I don't think that he has any alterior motives in his actions.  I have noticed that some are very quick with the support for him being Evil. (infact i am very impressed by the thought and determination of some people in this theory!!) The only thing I have to back up my feelings about Lupin is Crookshanks.  He is part Kneazle (which I have since found out are pretty good character judges (somewhere in Fantastic Beast)) and he seemed to be right on the money for Peter/Scabbers.  

If he was able to pick up the not so nice aspects of Peter he should have been able to with Lupin as well. Also he was very fond of Sirius which to me would indicate that Sirius is also on the up and up. I do not remember if Crookshanks had any reaction to Snape in the Shreiking Shake or not but this could shed some light onto Snapes true character.

It is not like JKR to give information about a character that could nto be used to help figure out theories and ideas. So these are just some of the thoughts I have.

animallover_11


		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! - Internet access at a great low price.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]