[HPforGrownups] Simple Snape math--addenuem

[Silverthorne]

No: HPFGUIDX 99712

You seem to persist  in mis-reading my posts.

Twice I have pointed out that the fly-zapper is almost certainly Snape
himself and not his child. 

I don't mind folk arguing about timelines and possibilities but I get
irritated when my posts are perverted to argue against a point that 
wasn't there in the first place.


Silverthorne:

My apologies for misreading your post and confusing the fly zapper for 'Snape's son'--I will admit to perhaps reading a bit too quickly, and since the main thrust if your arguement was *about* Snape's supposed son and his wife, I probably combined both examples mentioned in your post to both mean the son and not one as Snape--I am at work and reading in between truck shipments and calls for supplies usually, so I could very well get the various sentences a little twisted. It would not be the first time.

However, the still applies to the shouting match memory, where you *do* say the young boy is Snape's son and the parents are Snape himself and the wife (whether or not one chooses to believe it was a scene of abuse or not is another kettle of fish, and not the point I was trying to get to--as IIRC that was where you and potioncat went off on your own tangent and at which point I was no longer really paying attention). So, the math is still off.

Sorry for 'misreading' you, Kneasy. But after all is said and done, I am only human (and an easily distracted one at that sometimes...*g*). Hopefully, you are also human enough to forgive the mistake. *Winks*

Silverthorne/Anne


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]