Lupin Loved Lily

[earendil_fr]

No: HPFGUIDX 99719

> alina at d... writes:
> Here's a question though, did Lily and James know that Peter was 
> made Secret Keeper instead of Sirius? Seems to me their knowledge 
> isn't a prerequisit of the Secret spell.
> ===============
> Sherrie here:
> 
> Lily might not have known, but James certainly did - it was he who, 
with 
> Sirius, made the decision to switch to Pettigrew.

Earendil:
In PoA chapter 19, Sirius explains he 'convinced James AND Lily' 
(emphasise mine) to *chose* Peter, to *make him* their Secret Keeper. 
(I don't have the exact original wording since I only have a French 
version of PoA)

This answers both questions:
- Lily knew about the switch
- It's both James and Lily who took the decision, so they knew Peter 
was their Secret Keeper.