Lupin Loved Lily

[snapesmate]

No: HPFGUIDX 99810

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "earendil_fr" <viviane at l...> 
wrote:
So at the time of GH, James and Lily think Lupin shouldn't be trusted 
> and was (possibly) a traitor. I don't think Lupin would have been 
> welcome at GH back then - not to mention he wasn't supposed to know 
> the location.
> 
<snip>Second, she died protecting Harry, so she had to be 
> the one with Harry.
> 
> As for Lily not fleeing... Maybe someone blocked the way out while 
> James fought LV...
> 
> Earendil.


When I first viewed the clip it seemed as though Lupin did indeed 
love Lily, because he says a lot about her ability to love, her eyes, 
etc. and all he mentions about James is that he had a talent for 
mischief.  After chewing on it, I then realized it also lends a tad 
of creedence to that "swithing" theory stuff.  Up until seeing that 
clip I never believed in that theory.  That being said, as far as 
canon, Remus Lupin could NOT have been at the Potter home that night 
because he did not know the secret keeper had been ratboy.  The only 
way for him to be at the home would have been if THE secret keeper 
had told him where the Potters were.

Lynnette, who thinks Snape IS a good guy, even if he is NOT a nice
guy!
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/potterverseofadults