Lupin Loved Lily
vmonte
vmonte at yahoo.com
Sat May 29 11:25:21 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 99717
Earendil wrote:
We know from PoA that Sirius thought Lupin to be the traitor, and
adviced James and Lily to choose Peter as their Keeper (which means
they both knew who their Keeper was since *they* were the one who
*chose* him). It would be logical for Sirius to share his doubts
about Lupin with them, since he thought trusting Lupin would endanger
his friends' lives.
snip
OTOH, I don't think Lily trusted Harry to anyone. First, having just
discovered they were betrayed and being under LV's attack, I think
she wouldn't trust *anyone* at that point (with the possible
exception of DD). Second, she died protecting Harry, so she had to be
the one with Harry.
vmonte responds:
I agree that Lily was with Harry the whole time, and died protecting
him. I'm not sure about the voice we believe as being James, it might
be someone else; although I'm not certain it was Lupin.
Why do you suppose that Sirius believed that Lupin was the traitor?
And why did the Potter's believe him? Do you think that James
found out that Lupin was in love with Lily?
Also, it's too bad that James (if he was at GH) didn't change into a
stag and carry Lily and Harry out of the house to safety.
vmonte
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive