Prefects taking points solved-- NOT!!!!

Erin erinellii at yahoo.com
Tue Nov 2 04:42:01 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 117023


> Marcela wrote:
> *****I don't understand what you mean, Erin.  To me, it does solve 
> the 'missunderstanding' very well.
> 
> Fred and George are not Prefects but the Slytherin is one, he could 
> have very well docked points from the twins, what's more, the 
> Slytherin was a new IS member too, so he was entitled to dock 
points 
> from anybody, according to the new decrees.  And BTW, since when do 
> Gred and Forge need a reason to do any mischief? lol

Erin:
But, the problem is much more widespread than that.  Immediately 
after the Inquisitional Squad is given the power to dock points 
(according to the change, it's to dock points from other prefects) 
the Giant Hourglasses of the other three houses decline dramatically 
in jewels.

Well, other prefects simply can't affect it all that much.  Harry, 
for instance, is not a prefect.  If Malfoy has had the power all 
along to dock points from anyone who is not a prefect, why hasn't he 
taken a zillion points from Harry already?

They just got it totally wrong, IMO.

--Erin

 








More information about the HPforGrownups archive