Harry's 'Goodness' (was Re: Dirty Harry/Clean Harry)

[delwynmarch]

No: HPFGUIDX 117047


Alla wrote :
"I think this is a very GOOD example. Yes, we don't know whether other
champions CONSIDER telling Cedric about it, but we know that they DID
not DO it. They all saw dragons and only Harry decided to help out his
adversary."

Del replies :
How do we know that ? From what I remember, we only know that by the
time Harry tells Cedric, the other champions haven't told him yet. We
also know that Cedric feels grateful to Harry.

But that doesn't preclude the possibility that the other champions
told Cedric after Harry did.

And by the way, the other champions did not SEE the dragons. Their
trainers did. And we know that Harry felt an urge to tell Cedric
because he was horrified by the VISION of the dragons. So one could
argue that the other champions did not tell Cedric because they didn't
realise how awful things really were. Speculation, I agree, but not
more than the previous bits of speculation we've been discussing here.

Del