Harry's 'Goodness' (was Re: Dirty Harry/Clean Harry)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 117049


> Del replies :
> How do we know that ? From what I remember, we only know that by the
> time Harry tells Cedric, the other champions haven't told him yet. 
We
> also know that Cedric feels grateful to Harry.
> 
> But that doesn't preclude the possibility that the other champions
> told Cedric after Harry did.



Alla:

How do we know that other champions did not tell Cedric? Considering 
the fact that canon is silent on that point (granted in itself "no 
evidence" is not necessarily an evidence to the contrary) and Cedric 
never once mentions it to Harry or anybody else, I think it is more 
than a pure speculation , but a reasonable assumption to  make.


Del:
> And by the way, the other champions did not SEE the dragons. Their
> trainers did. 

Alla:

It is the same to me. Do you think that Madam Maxime did not describe 
it in all details to Fleur, for example?