Chapter 29, Career Advice - Broken Potion

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 117185


 "mcmaxslb" <McGregorMax at e...> wrote:
> 
>  I can't believe what I have read in this thread. Of course the 
> greasy git broke it on purpose! You Snape lovers have gone to far 
> this time. Snape is a complete and total asshole that takes out 
his 
> petty schoolboy grudges on a child to the extent that he 
undermines 
> the cause that he is fighting for! I hope that after Harry 
destroys 
> Voldemort he give Snivellus the beat down he deserves!

Potioncat:
So,erm, you don't like Snape?

OK.  It doesn't matter if a reader believes Snape broke it, or Draco 
broke it or it fell by happen chance....we all have dearly held and 
unchangable opinions.  But none of us know who broke it.

Unless some character from the book is given the line, "I saw 
Professor Snape break the flask," we could not convict Snape in a 
court of law.

OK, someone stop me before I post on this thread again.