Chapter 29, Career Advice - Broken Potion

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 117186


> Potioncat:
> So,erm, you don't like Snape?
> 
> OK.  It doesn't matter if a reader believes Snape broke it, or 
Draco 
> broke it or it fell by happen chance....we all have dearly held 
and 
> unchangable opinions.  But none of us know who broke it.
> 
> Unless some character from the book is given the line, "I saw 
> Professor Snape break the flask," we could not convict Snape in a 
> court of law.
> 
> OK, someone stop me before I post on this thread again.


Alla:

You have boldly gone to where no man have gone before , 
Potioncat. :o)

You dared to defend your favourite character.  How dare you? :)

Unfortunately, there is a possibility that Snape could be convicted 
in the court of law. Even with circumstantial evidence, it is 
possible. It all depends on how skilled the lawyer for prosecution 
will be (Trust me on this one :))


I guess I now broke my unspoken vow. Now I have to go and punish 
myself. Bad Alla, very bad Alla. :)