Who took more points from Gryffindors

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Thu Nov 11 05:05:52 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 117587


Potioncat: 
> > Actually, I think McGonagall has taken more points from 
Gryffindor  than Snape has when there has been a Gryffindor-
Slytherin conflict.  
> > (Late night out of bounds when she thinks Harry tricked Draco 
> about 
> > a dragon  and fist fight between Weasley/Potter and Malfoy after 
> > Quidditch game.)
> > 
> 
> 
> Alla:
> 
> She did, my Dear, definitely she did that time. :o) (Still think 
> that in general Snape took much more points from Gryffs over 
yeasr) 
> It speaks to her sense of fairness really well. Who knows, maybe 
at 
> the end of book 7 we'll see Snape taking at least on point of 
> Slytherin just for the sake of making me happy. :)

Potioncat again:
I'm sure Snape lives to make you happy. You enviable creature,you.
;-)

BTW, does anyone remember Snape ever giving anyone points?  I recall 
him praising Draco's skill at something or other, (slicing, dicing?) 
but I don't remember that he gave points for it.









More information about the HPforGrownups archive