Who took more points from Gryffindors

sbursztynski greatraven at hotmail.com
Thu Nov 11 08:33:23 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 117600


--- 
> 
> Potioncat again:
> I'm sure Snape lives to make you happy. You enviable creature,you.
> ;-)
> 
> BTW, does anyone remember Snape ever giving anyone points?  I
recall 
> him praising Draco's skill at something or other, (slicing,
dicing?) 
> but I don't remember that he gave points for it.

Sue:

Now you mention it, I don't remember him ever giving points even to
his own 
house. I suspect the author wouldn't let him do anything that
positive. But 
then - do you recall McGonagall ever giving any points? I don't.
Flitwick has, 
and Sprout and, of course, Dumbledore on the memorable occasion at
the 
end of the first novel. But either point-giving happens off-stage or
it's just not 
something teachers do that often. There has to be somewhere they're
getting 
all those hundreds of points, but we do know they get some from
Quidditch 
match wins. Not sure why, but I do vaguely recall the other students
being 
annoyed with Harry for losing points they had just won with the
Quidditch 
match.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive