[HPforGrownups] Re: Apparition lessons (was Re: Draco's POV?)

[Juli]

No: HPFGUIDX 117664


Juli wrote: 
> > Ooops, I forgot Hermione mentioned it about a thousand times in each and every book, plus Snape mentioned it in PoA, and Umbridge on OoP... If you know where to find the book, I'd like to be the second person to read it ;) Maybe they go to Hogsmeade for the Apparition lessons. 

Potioncat:
> Hmm, why do you supose JKR has told us so many times that no one can Apparate inside the Hogwarts grounds? Are we getting too comfortable with that information? What do you think would happen if someone forgot, and tried to Apparate? Some poor sleep deprived 7th year late for Potions class? I'd be urprised if no one had ever tried it. I mean, knowing how many students have a isregard for rules... <
 
I think if you tried to apparate/dispparate within the
castle gounds nothing would happen. Just like if right
now I tried to fly, it's not going to happen. If DD
could't dispparate in OoP when Fudge was about to
arrest him, so I doubt anyother student could, no
matter how hard they tried. On an other post (sorry, I
forgot who signed it) in this same thread, a teacher
just can't charm a room to make apparition possible.
Hogwarts is protected by very ancient magic, so how
could you just erase a thousand year old magic? An
other post says the students aren't allowed to do
magic outside Hogwarts, I don't think it applies to
Hogsmeade, Hermione did magic in PoA (she moved a tree
"mobilarbus" when Harry went without permission), and
I doubt Hermione would ever do magic if it wasn't
allowed, So they can't do magic outside Hogwarts,
Hogsmeade and the train, still they could learn how to
apparate at Hogsmeade.

Juli