Apparition lessons (was Re: Draco's POV?)

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Fri Nov 12 19:14:24 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 117700


> 
> Potioncat:
> Hmm, why do you supose JKR has told us so many times that no one 
can 
> Apparate inside the Hogwarts grounds? Are we getting too 
comfortable 
> with that information?  What do you think would happen if someone 
> forgot, and tried to Apparate? Some poor sleep deprived 7th year 
> late for Potions class? I'd be surprised if no one had ever tried 
> it. I mean, knowing how many students have a disregard for rules...

Finwitch:

Now, I think they have a theory test - and practical test, and one 
can't take the practical test unless they've passed the theory 
(including some sort of 'traffic' rules etc.)

And I do believe there are professional Apparation teachers, but that 
parents can also teach...

Well, just thinking that - with all the adults among Weasleys 
(possibly excluding Percy), they could teach Ron, Harry & Hermione. I 
suppose lessons can start early, (after OWLs?) but you're to take the 
test after (or as) you turn 17. (Meaning it gets to wait until book 
7).
 
Also, Hogwarts, A History says one *can't* disapparate from Hogwarts 
grounds - not that it's forbidden. (And Dumbledore doesn't do so when 
Fudge tried to arrest him - and I'd say that flying off with Fawkes 
is much more impressive-looking than just disappearing! - and AD 
could have pretended to disapparate, but only become invisible...)

Finwitch







More information about the HPforGrownups archive