Hagrid's attack on Dudley (Was: A few random puzzles)

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Fri Nov 12 17:49:46 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 117696


 
> Griffin782002 now:
> 
> I disagree a little with potioncat. Although Hagrid does seem to 
be prejudiced against Muggles, I don't think McGonagall is 
prejudiced. If I read it correctly, Mcgonagall says that they are 
the worst short of Muggles. It seems to me that there must a better 
sort of Muggles. I don't think she would say that for the Grangers.
> 
> I hope I made my points clear.
> 
> Griffin782002 who on Wednesday turned 26!!!! :-)
 
Potioncat:
Let me quickly say that I don't think McGonagall or Hargrid are 
bigots.  And I think all of us have a point where we are leary 
of "others." 

So you could have the worst sort of Muggles; or someone who very 
nice, for a Muggle; or someone who doesn't seem like a Muggle at all.

But I think Muggles are different enough to Hagrid and McGonagall to 
seem a bit strange, at best.

Potioncat who turns more than 26 on Monday.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive