Did DD lie about the Prophecy ?

[meriaugust]

No: HPFGUIDX 117783


Del wrote:

> First, let's examine what we believe about the circumstances
> surrounding the first prophecy.
> - It was delivered months before it would come true.
> - It was delivered when Trelawney was talking to DD in the middle 
of a
> crowded pub.
> - It was delivered to DD.

Meri now: I agree with numbers one and three, but IIRC the interview 
between DD and Trelawny was taking place in a room Trelawny rented 
above the bar at the Hog's Head. And this makes a little more sense, 
because a crowded bar is not the best place for a job interview, 
even one DD isn't planning to take that seriously. 
Meri