Sirius's Future

witchypooh67 witchypooh67 at yahoo.com
Mon Nov 15 01:08:05 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 117888




> 
> > Pippin
> > Oh, JKR, she knows her fans, yes she does. She dares us to 
> > ask her whether Sirius is really dead, and all the time she's 
> > laughing in her sleeve at us, because the question we *should* 
> > be asking is who killed him.


Now Kelly:

I agree, JKR knows us all very well and knows we will ponder the 
questions almost to ridiculum.  ;)  But I am confused about one 
thing.  Didn't Sirius fall through the veil while fighting Bella?  
When you say should we be asking who killed him are you suggesting 
he died later, after falling through the veil?  As for me, I'm still 
not totally convinced he is gone for good.  I think Harry (and the 
series) needs someone like Sirius, so we will see him (or hear from 
him) in some way in the future.










More information about the HPforGrownups archive