[HPforGrownups] Re: Sirius's Future/death

[Juli]

No: HPFGUIDX 117891


Charme:
> I agree with Pippin that the main question is who *did* kill Sirius; it's rather vague in canon and flows with his duel with Bella, however it certainly isn't clear at all. It does make me wonder about "friendly fire" - we all know it happens in a real battle so why wouldn't it happen in a multiple wizard duel? I also note that while there's much written in the DoM scene with other participants in the battle, there isn't as much about Lupin until *after* Sirius is hit.  I should wonder what that lack of detail should tell us?

Are you suggesting Lupin may have killed Sirius? I
just can't believe that, they were best friends, and
they still cared for each other (I'm thinking of the
Shrinking shack, Remus is in no way like Pettigrew, he
didn't become friends with the marauders to get their
protection, he just wanted friends. And we see it even
in OoP, like when Harry tells them Snape has stopped
teaching him Oclumency, Sirius wanted to give Snape a
piece of his mind, but Remus stopped him, why? because
he knew that if Sirius went to Hogwarts the MoM or the
DEs would get him, and he just couldn't handle it.
I don't believe in ESE!Lupin, he's just a nice guy
with bad luck.

I think Sirius died because he crossed the veil, Bella
didn't AK him, it was a a red ray, not a green, so he
could have been alive when he crossed over, so maybe
HUGE MAYBE, he could come back, and as much as I would
like it, I don't see it happening.

Juli