[HPforGrownups] Re: Sirius's Future/death

[charme]

No: HPFGUIDX 117940

From: "Juli"

> Are you suggesting Lupin may have killed Sirius? I
> just can't believe that, they were best friends, and
> they still cared for each other (I'm thinking of the
> Shrinking shack, Remus is in no way like Pettigrew, he
> didn't become friends with the marauders to get their
> protection, he just wanted friends. And we see it even
> in OoP, like when Harry tells them Snape has stopped
> teaching him Oclumency, Sirius wanted to give Snape a
> piece of his mind, but Remus stopped him, why? because
> he knew that if Sirius went to Hogwarts the MoM or the
> DEs would get him, and he just couldn't handle it.
> I don't believe in ESE!Lupin, he's just a nice guy
> with bad luck.
>
> I think Sirius died because he crossed the veil, Bella
> didn't AK him, it was a a red ray, not a green, so he
> could have been alive when he crossed over, so maybe
> HUGE MAYBE, he could come back, and as much as I would
> like it, I don't see it happening.
>

charme:

I'm suggesting that the possibility exists that someone other than Bellatrix 
uttered the curse that hit Sirius and caused him to fall through the Veil. I 
am also suggesting the canon is not as definitive about Lupin's action prior 
to his interdiction with Harry after Sirius fell through. I'm not suggesting 
Lupin is evil, just curious about who HE was dueling in the DoM - most, if 
not all, the other participants are paired.

charme