HP: Mystery or Adventure?

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 118000


> 
> Neri again:
> 
> We already had red-herring!Snape twice, in SS/PS and in GoF. 
BTW in  GoF he was only one suspect out of a bunch, probably 
because JKR  realized he's not much of a red herring anymore. 
Do you really think  the readers will fall for red-herring!Snape a 
third time? <

Pippin:
Harry has. Last I heard, he was determined to blame Sirius's 
death on Snape. Give him some concrete evidence that it's 
possible, and he'll fall for it, just like he fell for the false
vision of  the DoM. Sophisticated readers will know better, just as 
some of us knew to suspect the vision, but so what? The 
suspense-ridden question will not be whodunnit, but how will 
Harry react when he finds out?


Pippin