The Second Prophecy

[dungrollin]

No: HPFGUIDX 118031


> Dungrollin:
> But that didn't help Voldy to rise again, did it?  That was
> afterwards.  In order to make that bit of the prophecy apply to
> Sirius, you need to postulate how he could have been useful to 
> Voldy before the end of GoF.  What did Voldy need to rise again?  
> The information from Bertha Jorkins about the TWT and the stuff 
> behind the memory charm about Crouch The Younger being alive, some 
> help from Wormtail and Nagini... What else could Sirius have done 
> to qualify?
> 
> 
> Kneasy:
> The end of GoF? Why? The graveyard scene was just the resurrection.

Dungrollin:
Okay, I'll grudgingly grant you that. But...

Kneasy again:
> Q. Is Voldy greater and more terrible than ever?
> A. Like hell he is. He's in hiding along with the mad bitch and 
> his backing band is in the slammer.

Dungrollin:
And Sirius is now dead.  In which case, hasn't he left it a little 
late to be giving a helping hand on achieving greatness and 
terribleness surpassing previous efforts?

Or... You're not in sad denial too, are you...?

Dungrollin
Who's not so fond of smileys, but feels that a couple may be 
appropriate after that last comment...