JKR's writing in OoP (was Re: Sirius's Future)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 118101




Carol:
> If JKR brings Sirius back from behind the Veil, she will have
> tormented Harry for nothing, and she will deny him the lesson of 
the
> finality of death. Suppose that Sirius returns and then Ron is 
killed.
> Harry will expect him, too, to come back. That would be terrible 
for
> Harry and a cheat for the readers. Please, JKR. Let the dead remain
> dead. Don't give Harry or the readers false hope.
> 
> Carol, back from California and trying to respond only to recent 
posts
>


Alla:

Welcome back,Carol :o)

Or, if JKR brings Sirius  back, it may be for the reason unknown to 
us yet. It may be that he never was properly dead. Harry already 
learned the lesson the death is final (Cedric, his parents).

I think it would be wonderful for Harry and at least this reader if 
the only father figure this boy ever knew reenters his life again :o)

JKR planted the hints that Sirius may not be dead (different colour 
of the curse, no body, etc.) I don't see it as a cheat.

So, please, JKR, please, please :o)