SNAPE the coward?

[cubfanbudwoman]

No: HPFGUIDX 118152


"chrusotoxos" wrote:
> > >  But what if Voldemort sees SNAPE as  the coward, 
> > > and Karkaroff as the traitor? 

Valky:
> > I had a similar thought, but not as good, that DD trusts Snape 
> > because Snape is in his  protection, simple as that. Basically 
> > Snape needs a way out of Voldies gang but with out DD he's mince. 
 
Potioncat:
> It works very well either way and strong arguments have been made 
> for both views. JKR tells us that many have figured it out, but of 
> course she doesn't tell us who has the right answer.  I think it's 
> safe to say the 3 individuals are Crouch JR, Snape and Karkaroff.  
> (Although someone will disagree.) 
> 
> Is Snape set up for punishment or death?"  And how will he survive?


SSSusan:
Yes, the arguments *have* been made for Crouch, Jr., Snape & 
Karkaroff to be in these three slots, both with Snape as "gone 
forever" and Karkaroff as "coward" *and* with Snape as "coward" and 
Karkaroff as "gone forever".  There have also been those who've 
postulated that Snape actually managed to GET to the graveyard, 
though Harry didn't know it, and that the three Voldy referred to 
were Crouch, Jr., Karkaroff and someone else -- Bagman, perhaps?  I 
rather like this possibility, though of course logistically it 
would've been difficult for Snape to have pulled it off.

Siriusly Snapey Susan