SNAPE the coward?
Juli
jlnbtr at yahoo.com
Thu Nov 18 23:47:01 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 118165
--previous posts snipped--
chrusotoxos wrote:
> I've heard that some guys are sure that Snape was in
> the circle that night, and at one moment I was almost
> convinced...but there's still the fact, that, back in
> the hospital wing, Snape flinched when he heard that
> Malfoy was there...why would he? I mean, if he was
> there too, he must have known that Malfoy was there,
> because Voldemort called him by name. So my reasoning
> is that he could not have been there - <snip>
Juli now:
Let's remember that you CAN'T dispparate from
Hogwarts, Voldemort must know Snape is in Hogwarts and
since he studied there he must know the no-apparate
law, or LV placed Snape in Hogwarts as a spy, maybe
someday we'll find out.
Right after talking to Fudge on GoF, Dumbledore
assigns tasks: he asks Hagrid and Mme Maxime to his
office (to send them after the giants), Bill went to
let Arthur know about what happened, Sirius went to get
the old OoP members (Remus, Moody, Mrs Figg), and
Snape already knew what he had to do, and he actually
seemed scared about it, so I guess he went to find LV
and say what they all did "how great to see you back
sir" and started his work for the OoP undercover with
the DEs. He must have told LV "Sorry sir, you know I
was at Hogwarts and I couldn't dispparate, and DD was
there and I didn't want him to suspect, so here I am,
a little late but still your most loyal servant."
If Snape didn't go to Voldemort, his work would be
over, he could no longer spy for the Order and his
life would be at great risk, so I guess he went, but
after the DEs had left.
Juli
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive