bullies? twins, padfoot and prongs

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 118590


 Hickengruendler:
Is he? Well, maybe yes, as a Death Eater, that's possible. But I'm 
sure he wasn't killing people as a student. If he were, and 
everybody would have known that, than for sure he would be in 
Azkaban.
 
> Alla:
> 
> I think Valky was talking about Voldemort, not Snape, actually.


 Hickengruendler,
 who really thinks, that if the storyline weren't 
 told from Harry's point of view but from a more objective one, 
Sirius would look as bad as Snape. A nasty, prejudiced and dangerous 
man (with a sad life, that makes his behaviour undertandable), who 
nonetheless decided to fight for the good site. It's just Harry's 
rose-coloured point of view, that makes look Sirius better.



Alla:

Ummm, I am not saying that Sirius is much better than Snape ( I like 
him more, but it certainly has nothing to do with the story), BUT if 
we are saying that Snape is essentially GOOD, only because he 
eventually decided to fight on Dumbledore's side, shouldn't the same 
be true for Sirius?

By the way, from the facts we have right now, it certainly took 
Sirius' less time of his life than Snape to figure out who the good 
guys are. Unless, of course you beliee in ESE! Sirius.