When?

[kjirstem]

No: HPFGUIDX 118620


Kneasy wrote:
> ...said Voldemort softly. "Answer me! Imperio!"
> And Harry felt *for the third time in his life*, the sensation...
> (my emphases).
> 
> Third time?
> Does not compute.

kjirstem:

I've always wondered about that line myself.  I took it to mean the
number of times that he felt the sensation rather than the number of
times he was Imperioed.  I thought the Crouch!Moody lesson only
counted as one time; on subsequent trials during the lesson perhaps
the sensation was reduced from the first Imperio.

I tend to think the other time was before PS/SS.  I've wondered what
would have happened if Lily Imperioed Harry and told him to live.  We
don't hear that happen in the dementor induced memories, but I'm not
sure those are reliable.