Sirius' death (was: Dept of Mysteries Veil Room)

[Julia]

No: HPFGUIDX 114424


Aura said:

> All we have is circumstantial evidence: characters have said that Sirius
> is dead, but no one saw a body and no one specifically said what that
> veil was. All other info about his fate was (deliberatly) misleading. If
> JKR wanted to bring him back (which I don't see as very likely, but for
> the sake of argument, cuz that's what we live off of on this group), all
> she would have to say is that Dumbledore and Lupin were wrong. It isn't
> lying about death to say that characters were wrong. Lying about death
> would be bringing back Cedric. 
> 
> Just sayin. I won't believe he's gone until I see his cold, dead, sexy
> body. :)

Julia:
Yes... I would really love to believe that she will someday bring him back but 
I'm afraid to say that it will never gonna happen! IMO the Sirius' death 
represents JKR's mother's death. It's normal that the writer wrtites about 
things s/he knows - it's some kind of dealing with it. So if in the real life JKR's 
mother died and she didn't come back after a month or two we can be almost 
sure that Sirius won't come back either. It's that JKR know how to write about 
Harry's feeling after his loss because they are the same as her. She won't 
bring Sirius back because it's not how the world works and she knows it! And 
besides this loss will have a strong impact on Harry and it will help him to 
mature - in the same way it helped JKR...

Nevertheless I'd love to see his sexy body again in the books :P

Julia