[HPforGrownups] Re: Sirius' death (was: Dept of Mysteries Veil Room)

[sp. sot.]

No: HPFGUIDX 114639



macfotuk at yahoo.com wrote:
(EDIT)
Mac: No nor me either. I took JKR at her word, when she said (not a 
quote) that when someone is dead they stay dead. And yes I think 
he's dead because JKR said he 'had' to die and we would find out why.

 

Griffin782002 now:

Well she has said that. But what about the "properly dead"? Unless of course it means being a ghost or a form like L.V. was before the end of G.o.F.

I made search a few days ago using the word 'veil'. It came up with various results, some of them with refering to those near-death expiriences. I didn't look at these articles for more details but some mentioned "beyond the veil expiriences". I only checked the results of the search and I am not sure when they were written. This made me think about what I have heard about these. Some have said that they "saw" dead relatives, who tell them something like "it's not your time yet, go back." And, sorry but I still do not understand how a veil kills  

 

Also mac said  

It's that finding out why which, in my view, contains the nub of my 
comment that he would return - not physically (though Harry may talk 
with him 'beyond the veil' somehow or even as a past 'mirror image' -
memory that Sirius may have left behind, like TMR's in the diary). 
Who knows? I'm not even going to try to guess.

 

Griffin782002 again:

I know that she said something like that in the World Book Day Webchat. But if someone asked her if James or Lily would return, would it be possible to answer the same way?

Griffin782002 who will not stop reading the books even if she proves wrong




		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail - 50x more storage than other providers!

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]