New thoughts on Sirius

[Jen Reese]

No: HPFGUIDX 114719


I'll add a little spoiler space for anyone who hasn't looked at the 
FAQ updates.

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

So JKR was asked, "Do you like Sirius Black?" and her response was, 
well, less than glowing. She specifically points out all his flaws 
in record time, including his penchant for "spouting bits of 
personal philosophy" but not always living up to them (i.e. how he 
treats Kreacher). 

What happened to Sirius being one of her favorite characters? That 
she couldn't wait to get to POA and write about Lupin & Sirius? Will 
Lupin next on the chopping block?!?

Basically she distills Sirius down to a 'slightly unbalanced' person 
with one great quality--feeling great affection for James, which he 
then transferred to Harry.

I felt a little let-down by her characterization. Not that she said 
anything untrue of course ;), but she seems to be wavering on her 
view of Sirius, like she was influenced by fandom casting the cold 
light of day on the character. It's like hearing your Mom trash your 
brother behind his back: "Oh well, that one...yes, well we tried but 
he's been a big disappointment."

Jen, wondering if JKR is back-pedaling or merely bringing to light 
her true feelings on the subject.