Carpets and Muggles
ohnooboe
hautbois1 at comcast.net
Mon Oct 4 16:38:32 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 114729
I found myself wondering this morning (on my way to work) about how a
Muggle Artifact is defined by the MoM. In GoF there is a lot of talk
about magic carpets and illegally importing them. Because they are
Muggle artifacts, charming a carpet to fly breaks wizarding law
(Registry of Proscribed Charmable Objects, GoF).
I find myself wondering what exactly is defined as a muggle
artifact. I suppose something that only muggles use, like cars,
which would explain all the trouble Arthur Weasley found himself in
after the Anglia incident. But, what about the Knight Bus--why is
this not included in the ban? If we go with muggle artifacts being
things only muggles use, why carpets? I would guess that carpets are
not unknown in the homes of wizards.
Why can pots and pans be charmed (CoS), but not carpets?
Why a triple-decker bus, but not a Ford Anglia?
I know the argument exists that flying carpets may pose a "security
risk" (imagine a family flying over your head on grandma's antique
Persian rug) but Mad-Eye showed us how to solve that problem in OoP
(the Disillutionment Charm).
Just a thought on one of the "little things".
Patrick
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive