Stopping Occlumency

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 114792


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Alex Boyd" <alex51324 at h...> 
wrote:
> 
> Oh, and here's another random thought--eductional decree number 26,
> banning all teachers from giving students information not "strictly
> related to the subjects they are paid to teach" is in effect by the
> time Snape refuses to teach Harry Occlumency anymore.  And 
Dumbledore
> is gone.  I'm not totally sure, in Snape's place, that I would be
> entirely willing to *break the law* to teach a student I didn't 
like,
> and who didn't like me.  


Doddiemoe here:

Death eathers escaped, dementors not under misitry control...why 
would snape continue teaching Harry Occlumency after he already 
found out the information he needed to know during said "Lessons"...
SWhat if Harry get sent to aunt marge's after what snape 
saw?!?!?!?!?!?(and how knows what sort of memory modifacation was 
performed upon her)????!!!!!

Perhaps DD was listening to Harry, Ron, Hermione...and giving his 
own investigation?!?!?

DD may be able to trust Snape not to betray him(dumbledor), however 
snape may be devious enough to betray Harry, Ron, Hermione...and 
anyone else he does not see as being physically tied(relations) to 
Dumbledor. Perhaps DD gave snape the job to see how well he 
did...hence the delay from when Harry was in DU's office until the 
time Snape sent help.

Snape, like DD is a leguimens...I would not be surprised if dd 
beheaded Kreacher and gave him a plaque on the wall of his 
ancestors...after what happened...I would be even less surprised if 
Snape turned up first and told kreacher what to tell DD..(remember 
Harry told snape first during the office scene of oop)...I don't 
believe dd when he says that old grudges stuff...

  I do believe that DD trusts Snape...but I don't believe that is 
what he should do....thus far in the books...we are coming to the 
point where dd is right or he's not...aside from wooly socks...he's 
been pretty much gray...the few aspects we should consider, Harry's 
peers...one of them is right at least one time during all the 
books..We as the reader never see DD's pov BECAUSE just too many of 
the players are SPECULATING, or have family business of their own is 
going on.

I find it rather interesting that DD trusts when snape/lv/bl 
etc...involve themselves in wizarding today...but makes no sense as 
gto what any of the kids say..

Doddie