Snape--Abusive?

M.Clifford Aisbelmon at hotmail.com
Tue Oct 5 05:29:34 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 114802



> Alla:
> I think Harry saving his life will be
> perfect,ESPECIALLY if Harry will do it with the best intentions in
> mind - not wanting to humiliate Snape , but to keep him alive.
> 
> Casey:
> Just as Snape has already tried to save Harry's life, with no 
> acknowledgement or thanks from Harry for that act.

Valky:
That's not fair Casey! Harry *really* did want to acknowledge what 
Snape did. He *was* grateful, but Snape never exactly gave him the 
chance to show it. 
The next time Harry sees Snape after he discovers that Snape saved 
him their eyes meet and Harry *knows* Snape still hates him as much 
as ever so he keeps his distance. 
It's not fair to say that Harry did not want to acknowledge it when 
clearly he didn't because he couldn't. 
Whether he wanted to or not doesn't come into it, but I sincerely 
believe Harry would have walked right up and thanked Snape 
personally had Snape ever appeared open to it.
 







More information about the HPforGrownups archive