Should Neville Stand or Sit in Defiance WAS Re: Snape

[cubfanbudwoman]

No: HPFGUIDX 115368


HunterGreen:
> > When it comes to Neville, I have to agree with Carol in this 
> > situation, I can't see him being the type to defy a teacher, nor 
> > do I think it would be appropriate. However, a scene where 
> > Neville stands up to Snape (beyond the Boggart!Snape scene in 
> > PoA), would be interesting, and good for him. I think it would 
> > work better if it happened in a non-classroom scene (however, 
> > Snape has little reason to bully Neville beyond potions class).

Dzeytoun: 
> I also don't see how a scene outside potions could be arranged.  I
> guess if Snape became advisor of the DA, it might work.  I 
> certainly hope Dumbledore wouldn't be that silly, however.  He's 
> caused enough problems with his idealistic illusions about Harry 
> and Snape working together.


SSSusan:
Yikes!  Snape as DA advisor?!?  My first reaction was, "Oooooh, bad 
idea!"  Is there anybody out there who could argue that it would be 
a GOOD idea, though?  

Just curious,
Siriusly Snapey Susan